Elon Musk’s X sues media non-profit over portrayal of site as ‘full of anti-Semitism’
Elon Musk’s X Corp. has sued non-profit Media Matters for driving advertisers away from the platform formerly known as Twitter by portraying it as rife with anti-Semitic content.
In a lawsuit filed in US federal court in Texas, X accuses the organisation of “tricking the algorithm into thinking Media Matters wanted to view both hateful content and content from large advertisers.” Apple, Comcast, NBCUniversal and IBM were among high-profile brands that paused advertising on X last week after Media Matters reported finding ads displayed with pro-Nazi content.
The advertising exodus also came in the wake of Musk endorsing an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory.
“This is a frivolous lawsuit meant to bully X’s critics into silence,” Media Matters president Angelo Carusone said in response to an AFP inquiry.
“Media Matters stands behind its reporting and looks forward to winning in court.” The White House has condemned Musk, the world’s richest person, for “abhorrent promotion” of anti-Semitism.
The White House was reacting to a post by Musk in which the controversial Tesla and SpaceX tycoon replied to an anti-Semitic post on X with the words: “You have said the actual truth.”
The original post has been widely seen as a reference to a longtime false conspiracy theory among White supremacists that Jews have a secret plan to bring illegal immigrants into the United States to move US demographics away from a white majority.
Most notoriously, the idea was promoted by the man who carried out a mass shooting at a synagogue in Pittsburgh in 2018, killing 11 people.
Referring to Musk’s post, White House spokesman Andrew Bates said it was “unacceptable” to repeat such a “hideous lie.” The suit filed Monday does not mention Musk’s endorsement of the conspiracy theory, instead blaming recent ad woes on Media Matters.
“Media Matters knowingly and maliciously manufactured side-by-side images depicting advertisers’ posts on X Corp.’s social media platform beside Neo-Nazi and white-nationalist fringe content and then portrayed these manufactured images as if they were what typical X users experience,” the lawsuit contended.
X accused Media Matters of duping its algorithm by following only accounts known for extreme, fringe content along with big-name brands.
The result was a feed “precision-designed” to produce the kind of side-by-side ad and content pairings that alienated X advertisers, the suit maintained.
Musk has since declared “Media Matters is pure evil”, posting to his 163 million followers on Tuesday.
X asked the court to order Media Matters to pay unspecified cash damages and to take down the report.
In the year since taking over Twitter, now rebranded as X, Musk has gutted content moderation, restored accounts of previously banned extremists, and allowed users to purchase account verification, helping them profit from viral — but often inaccurate — posts.
An X executive told AFP that it did a “sweep” of accounts pointed out by Media Matters and they will no longer be able to make money from ads.
The posts themselves will be labelled “sensitive media,” according to the executive.
The lawsuit followed another controversy where X failed to pay a $610,500 fine over its failure to answer questions on how it removes and tackles child sexual exploitation and sexual extortion.
In October, X was slapped with the fine for failing to respond to a legal notice demanding tech giants disclose how they were preventing and managing illegal material from being circulated on their platforms.
While the infringement asked for payment within 28 days, the office of the eSafety Commissioner confirmed on Wednesday that X had failed to settle the debt.
“Twitter/X was given an Infringement Notice for a sum of $610,500 for failure to comply with the non-periodic reporting notice given to it in February this year,” a spokesperson said.
“Twitter/X has not paid the infringement notice within the allotted timeframe and eSafety is now considering further steps.”
While both Google and X failed to adequately respond to a number of questions in the legal notice, X’s noncompliance was found to be more serious.
eSafety said sections were left entirely blank, with X also providing answers which were incomplete and/or inaccurate.
Questions around the number of safety and public policy staff still employed at Twitter/X following Musk’s October 2022 acquisition and subsequent job cuts, were also left unanswered.
Google was also issued a formal warning for providing a number of generic responses to specific information and “providing aggregated information when asked questions about specific services”.